One Year On – D&D Essentials Kit

My first look at The Essentials Kit a year ago wasn’t so much a review, but more of a First Thoughts post, as I hadn’t actually played the game at that point, just read through the rules and looked at the included components (I had played D&D before, but that was 2nd edition!). I was quite excited to jump in, as I’d been searching for something that could be played with a single player and with the introduction of Sidekicks, they reckoned you can do just that.

D&D Essentials Kit

Read my ‘First Thought’ HERE

Well, after several sessions I have to say I have some reservations about the Kit, mainly as to who it is aimed at. It is supposedly an introduction into the world of Dungeons and Dragons, but I wouldn’t say that it entirely fits the bill.

Certainly, a group of new players shouldn’t have a problem and I would recommend it as a starting point, but with one caveat, the GM needs to have some experience, either as a player or in RPGs, preferably within the D&D universe.

The included campaign, Dragon of Icespire Peak, is fairly typical of how D&D campaigns are these days. Gone are the more linear adventures of old that I grew up on, and now we have these ‘sandbox’ type of adventures. Now, this is great for the players, they can go anywhere and do anything, within limits, but for a new GM it creates nothing but a headache.

As I ran the game I tried to think of how a new GM would see things, not too difficult as I’m a little rusty myself, and came to the conclusion that it would appear quite overwhelming, reducing the game to a crawl.

The ‘sandbox’ nature, especially at the start of the campaign, means that the GM needs to be prepared for the players to take on any of the first three scenarios. An experienced GM would cope with this easily, as one knows just how much prep they need to do for their playstyle. For some, that’s next to nothing as they like to ‘cuff’ it, for others it may mean having copious notes for the unavoidable encounters. There are also tricks one learns for steering the players in the direction you want them to go, especially handy if you haven’t the time, or will, to prep for all eventualities.

But for someone approaching this for the first time it makes for an uphill struggle. There’s also the encounters, which I found had to be adjusted on the fly, especially in terms of level – I was only playing with a single player which didn’t help – and again, this is something a new GM may struggle with. It isn’t helped by the lack of an index in the rulebook, which makes finding things an exercise in flipping pages – not that it tells you much about encounter level anyway!

I concluded that the rulebook does do a decent job of introducing people to the world of D&D, but the included campaign should perhaps be simpler and more linear to aid a new GM. It would also help to include pointers on how to deal with situations and how to adapt when things go awry.

I also found the Dragon of Icespire Peak, well, a bit boring! For me it lacked any real impact, with many of the scenarios finishing before they got going.

I also had another issue with the kit, and that was with trying to play with just a single player – a new one at that. With the introduction of Sidekicks, the game is supposed to be playable like this, but after several hours playing I would say it isn’t, at least not comfortably.

I found that including the sidekicks shifted the emphasis away from the player. With a single player I included two Sidekicks at first, but more time was spent using them than on the player’s turn. We tried a mixture of the GM and/or player controlling the Sidekicks, as well as how exactly they were used – like a mindless retainer or more like an NPC – but we didn’t find anything that let the game flow.

That’s the other thing I found, they’re called ‘Sidekicks’, but depending on how you run them they’re no different from using retainers or NPCs, and I eventually ended up creating them as fully fledged NPCs, as it was easier to keep track of exactly what they could do, what they were carrying, and their state of wellbeing.

Without the sidekicks a single player, or indeed a small group, just isn’t powerful enough to adventure out alone – maybe at higher levels they could, by taking on a campaign a couple of levels lower than themselves. However, I do think that Sidekicks would work better when they are included in a group of two or three players. They could then be used like a retainer and the focus would remain on the players.

Coming back to the included campaign, Yasmin, as a new player, found it really difficult to grasp exactly what was required of her, again it was partially due to the sandbox nature of the adventure. She couldn’t see how the individual scenarios related to each other or what the overall aim of them was. That’s a common issue with single player RPGs, there’s nobody to bounce ideas off other than the GM, which isn’t ideal and can cause things to stutter and bog down as the GM tries to help the player without leading them and giving too much away.

Knowing what I know now, would I still have bought it? No. It doesn’t do what I wanted it to do and that was give me an easy means to play one-on-one. The sidekicks just don’t do it, as far as I’m concerned.

Will it remain in my collection? Conversely, yes! At some point I may want to run an RPG again for a group, and this is a good place to start.

So, One Year On – The Essentials Kit is a great way to introduce new players to the world of D&D, however, having an experienced GM run the game would make things so much easier. The introduction of Sidekicks doesn’t add anything that couldn’t be done with retainers or NPCs, and it certainly doesn’t make the game playable for a single player. Personally, I’ll keep looking for something that does, whether it be within the D&D universe or somewhere else entirely.

11 thoughts on “One Year On – D&D Essentials Kit

  1. Enjoyed this, Justin! 🙂 I am not a D&D/RPG kinda person, but it was interesting hearing how you found it as a GM!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks John.
      Would have been better with a group; still looking for something that works one-on-one.
      Call of Cthulhu next, which has scenarios written specifically for that type of play, plus a few solo ones too.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. So if the madness that is lockdown doesn’t get you, then Cthulhu will! 😉

        Liked by 1 person

  2. Interesting read. Much of the D&D books were on sale during Black Friday, so I picked some up. I played 1e-2e, but 3rd edition just wasn’t for me. Hopefully this latest edition is much better. I head the Starter box module might be more linear than the module in Essentials. Even so, I guess you’d still have to deal with balancing and/or sidekicks. We always used NPCs because we seldom had enough players.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I liked 2e, it’s where I started, bu then moved to Palladium and other things.
      I feel 5e has more emphasis on the role-playing side of things, as the mechanisms are really quite simple… and, dare I say it, a little boring!
      I only went for the Essentials kit because of the sidekicks. In hindsight the starter would probably have served better. I’m not exactly sure who the Essentials kit is aimed for having played it and the sidekicks certainly don’t make the game work one-on-one, at least for me.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. I started with 1e. First book we bought was AD&D Players Handbook, and then we had to wait a long time to get the Monster Manual. Seems pretty funny nowadays.

        I’ll have to see how I feel about 5e. 3e felt too much like we were trying to recreate a video game using dice. I generally prefer simpler systems that let the DM spend more time playing out the adventure and the characters. But everyone has different likes and play styles.

        Liked by 1 person

      2. I think you’ll probably like 5e then, it’s appears to be a simple system and combat is a single D20 roll. Obviously, I’m only basing this on my experiences of the Essentials kit and listening to a few very good D&D podcasts (Encounter Party is excellent!).
        Myself, I prefer more complexity in the mechanism – I love a good table to consult – and I like to base the roleplaying around this, at least I do as a GM. I haven’t actually played a character for what seems a lifetime, and think that the simplicity of D&D may appeal more to me nowadays in that respect.

        Liked by 1 person

      3. Hmm, will have to see. There is definitely a line where “too simple” does get very boring. Thanks for the podcast suggestion too, will have to check that out!

        Liked by 1 person

  3. Bernie Stoker Jul 5, 2021 — 16:33

    The contents remind me greatly of the original d&d boxed set but reworked to be consistent with 5e. My thought is it will be easier for beginers to grow from original to advanced d&d then into expansions without having to relearn rules or adapt and rework their characters and worlds to next editions. I am planning to gift it to an imaginative and sometimes cheeky grandchild.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Yes, I had the old red and blue boxed sets – basic and expert – and really enjoyed them. I then took the leap to advanced and wondered why I didn’t start there!
      This set gets you straight into the ‘real’ game and is a great entry for young and old, however cheeky they may be!

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Chicago Dice

Rolling in the Windy City since 2015

Wargamesculptors Blog

Tabletop Games Blog, News, Reviews and more...

PM Painting

Tabletop Games Blog, News, Reviews and more...

WarGamer Eric's Hobby and Gaming Emporium

“All you need to paint is a few tools, a little instruction, and a vision in your mind.” ― Bob Ross

candore et labore

A Blog about any Thoughts in my Head: Politics, Writing, Life

Kuribo's Painting

Painting, Terrain, Dioramas, and Battle Reports Middle Earth Strategy Battle Game and Fallout

Scent of a Gamer

From the computer to the tabletop, this is all about games. Updated each week-end.

Model Airplane Maker

Building and improving scale models

Dagger and Brush

Miniature painting, wargaming terrain tutorials, reviews, interviews and painting guides

INSPIRING MONOLOGUE

A Blog About Marvel Crisis Protocol - The Tabletop Miniatures Game by Atomic Mass Games

despertaferres

Wargaming with the ability of a dull nine year old

Double Down Dice

Painting miniatures and rolling dice!

Fighting Toy Stories

Exploring vintage military toys

From the Lands and from the Landsknecht

A Miniature (Painting) Blog

Skarloc´s

Collecting, modelling, painting and wargaming in 28mm

Xavier Protocols

Level up your Marvel: Crisis Protocol game with more XP.

The Archon and the Seer

A Warhammer 40k Drukhari, Craftworlds, Ynnari, and all things Aeldari Resource

Faith&Steel

dave's gaming adventures: faithandsteel.wordpress.com

The Regimental Standard

Required weekly reading for the modern guardsman

Ann's Immaterium

Writing, gaming, miniature painting, physical culture, and other dark procrastinations.

Just Needs Varnish!

My ongoing wargames projects!

Mark A. Morin

Life, Golf, Miniatures, & Other Distractions

Bird with a Brush

Art in many forms

Sagenwelt

28mm historical fantasy war gaming

Deathzap

Anyone can afford wargaming!

Painting In The Dark

A Warhammer 40k blog, written by conversion enthusiasts - Krakendoomcool, Pandorasbitzbox, Warbringer, davyArt & Ritual. Featuring The Wolf Lord Project (making all twelve Wolf Lords). Lots of conversions, Space Wolves, Chaos, Salamanders, Tyranids & More!

%d bloggers like this:
search previous next tag category expand menu location phone mail time cart zoom edit close